Code of Conduct: Difference between revisions
From HacDC Wiki
Ubuntourist (talk | contribs) m (Signed) |
(→preliminary comments: new section) |
||
Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
Given the nature of our "open house" nights, which I would not consider to be a "scheduled workshop" this line will probably need to go or we will need to start re-educating some of the regulars... | Given the nature of our "open house" nights, which I would not consider to be a "scheduled workshop" this line will probably need to go or we will need to start re-educating some of the regulars... | ||
--[[User:Ubuntourist|Ubuntourist]] ([[User talk:Ubuntourist|talk]]) 08:32, 10 April 2018 (PDT) | --[[User:Ubuntourist|Ubuntourist]] ([[User talk:Ubuntourist|talk]]) 08:32, 10 April 2018 (PDT) | ||
== preliminary comments == | |||
General comment: It is important to CLEARLY distinguish between rules and requests. They are definitely not the same. | |||
Do: Ask questions - Don't - Interrupt presentations, workshops, or mentoring sessions - contradictory! | |||
conduct that consists of loud or boisterous physical behavior or talking. This includes all forms of harassment - no, it doesn't. It is possible to harass someone quietly & nonboisterously. I suggest splitting this: | |||
excessively loud talking or boisterous behavior | |||
harassment of any kind (but constitutionally-protected free speech by itself cannot constitute harassment) | |||
directing a specific threat of physical harm against an individual, group of individuals, or property - suggested rewording: making a specific threat to cause harm to an individual, group, or property | |||
I recommend adding: leave the space open without a member present | |||
Safety Rules - they should be rules, not requests as currently written | |||
Cleaning up and putting away equipment belongs elsewhere; it is not a safety issue (unlike shutting off or unplugging equipment is). | |||
Possible addition: No horseplay in the space - there is too much dangerous or fragile stuff here | |||
Guests - recommended tool use rules: | |||
Guests may use nonhazardous tools in a proper manner. | |||
Guests may use hazardous tools they are familiar with in a proper manner if monitored by a member. | |||
Guests may be taught to use an unfamiliar tool by a member familiar with that tool. | |||
Anyone who misuses a tool may be barred from using HacDC tools. (Note that this allows HacDC to bar someone who misuses their own tools from using HacDC tools, which seems like a good idea.) | |||
Members are responsible for their guests and their actions - suggested rewording: Members are responsible for monitoring guests. | |||
Minors - I strongly oppose this entire section. HacDC should not discriminate. | |||
I will undoubtedly come up with much more. | |||
Bobby |
Revision as of 22:39, 10 April 2018
Grammatical correction
- Delete of after Misuse under Safety Rules (Bobby)
- Good catch. Done. Thanks.
A deletion or a culture shift
* Guests are not allowed to use tools and equipment except as part of a scheduled workshop.
Given the nature of our "open house" nights, which I would not consider to be a "scheduled workshop" this line will probably need to go or we will need to start re-educating some of the regulars... --Ubuntourist (talk) 08:32, 10 April 2018 (PDT)
preliminary comments
General comment: It is important to CLEARLY distinguish between rules and requests. They are definitely not the same. Do: Ask questions - Don't - Interrupt presentations, workshops, or mentoring sessions - contradictory! conduct that consists of loud or boisterous physical behavior or talking. This includes all forms of harassment - no, it doesn't. It is possible to harass someone quietly & nonboisterously. I suggest splitting this: excessively loud talking or boisterous behavior harassment of any kind (but constitutionally-protected free speech by itself cannot constitute harassment) directing a specific threat of physical harm against an individual, group of individuals, or property - suggested rewording: making a specific threat to cause harm to an individual, group, or property I recommend adding: leave the space open without a member present Safety Rules - they should be rules, not requests as currently written Cleaning up and putting away equipment belongs elsewhere; it is not a safety issue (unlike shutting off or unplugging equipment is). Possible addition: No horseplay in the space - there is too much dangerous or fragile stuff here Guests - recommended tool use rules: Guests may use nonhazardous tools in a proper manner. Guests may use hazardous tools they are familiar with in a proper manner if monitored by a member. Guests may be taught to use an unfamiliar tool by a member familiar with that tool. Anyone who misuses a tool may be barred from using HacDC tools. (Note that this allows HacDC to bar someone who misuses their own tools from using HacDC tools, which seems like a good idea.) Members are responsible for their guests and their actions - suggested rewording: Members are responsible for monitoring guests. Minors - I strongly oppose this entire section. HacDC should not discriminate.
I will undoubtedly come up with much more.
Bobby